Theo Bleak documents grief and memory on Bargaining
Dundee-based artist Theo Bleak returns with Bargaining, her new album out December 18, 2025. Released under her solo moniker, the project, rooted in atmospheric, introspective alternative rock, captures an unfiltered emotional arc shaped by grief, change, and self-reckoning.
Produced by: Katie Lynch, Mark Johnston, Kieran Smith, Mike McGuire, and Dan Marcellus
At its core, Bargaining unfolds as a raw and deliberate exploration of grief’s most disorienting stage. The album leans into a restrained sonic palette that favors intimacy over polish, allowing vulnerability to slither through both structure and tone. Rather than seeking resolution, the record sits with uncertainty, tracing moments of reflection, memory, and confrontation as they surface in real time.
Sonically, the album strikes a balance between understated alternative rock and elements of emo and textural indie songwriting. Sparse arrangements, muted dynamics, and unvarnished performances give the songs a lived-in quality, reinforcing the project’s diaristic intent. Across its 14-track runtime, Bargaining moves fluidly between recollection and immediacy, emphasizing emotional continuity over dramatic peaks.
Several tracks stand out as emotional anchors within the album’s arc. The opening track, ‘End of Bargaining,’ establishes the project’s reflective tone, grounding the record in acceptance and emotional exhaustion. Later on, ‘Megan in New York’ and ‘NJ Transit’ evoke place and movement, using geography as a lens for distance and longing. Later, ‘The Light in Your Eyes Faded Too’ and ‘My Name Lives in Your Throat’ narrow in on loss and connection, capturing the lingering weight of relationships that persist beyond their physical presence.
Theo Bleak describes the album as a deeply personal time capsule. On Bargaining, she says:
“A chronological mixtape of my year through the most intense stage of grief I experienced- bargaining. Coming to terms with change, which felt unsurpassable, deep love, and brutal honesty. My mixtape was recorded at each of the rawest, saddest moments. The creak of my studio chair was audible in some of the tracks where I sat down to reason with my life, my mistakes, and my choices.
“I navigated the mess of my life over the last year, inspired by the complex philosophy hidden within simple sentiments, imparted through my late Great Uncle’s journals. I read and annotated these, rich with his passion for cycling. These diaries begin in 1966, and although John died in the early 2000s, I could feel the friendship as though the veil was thin between the living and the dead. My best friend.”
Operating as the musical project of Katie Lynch, Theo Bleak has steadily built a reputation for weaving personal narrative into immersive soundscapes since debuting with Fragments (2022). Drawing influence from alternative rock, emo, and visual storytelling, her work consistently prioritizes emotional clarity and atmosphere. With Bargaining, that approach becomes more explicit, foregrounding process over performance and reflection over resolution.
Bargaining stands as a focused album review-worthy release that documents grief without abstraction or excess. Out December 18, 2025, the new album marks a defining chapter in Theo Bleak’s evolving body of work and is available to stream upon release.
Standout Songs: ‘End of Bargaining,’ ‘Megan in New York,’ ‘Finest Work,’ ‘So Glad I Waited,’ and ‘NJ Transit.’
Release Date: December 18, 2025
7.4
We’ve covered Theo Bleak previously: ‘Said Like a Poet,’ and ‘Peach Sky.’
Connect with Theo Bleak:
We’re an independent, ad-free music publication, and we rely on the support of readers like you to keep things running. If you enjoy what we do, consider buying us a beer—every contribution helps us stay focused on bringing you quality music news without the clutter.
More music reviews from the team at The Daily Music Report can be found here.